After losing hope of conceiving a child on their own, Christy and Mitch turn to surrogacy in hopes of creating the perfect family. However, their confidence is quickly shaken when they discover that the young woman might not be as perfect as they first thought.
Christy (Mia Kirschner) and Mitch Bennett (David Julian Hirsch) are unable to have a child. They use an online "person to surrogate" match up and find Mallory Parks (Rachel Blanchard), a seemingly polite, graceful and emotionally stable woman. They choose her as their surrogate and she becomes pregnant with their child. But after a while, Mallory starts calling them, comes to their house, and starts acting incredibly needy. She has their baby, but a series of incidents drive Mallory over the edge. Will Christy and Mitch get the family they crave, or will Mallory get the only thing Christy ever wanted?